Buyer's Guide to Emerald Gemstones

Home · Gemstone Education · Emerald
Gemstone Buying Guides

The Emerald Buying Guide

The gemstone of Venus and the green of spring itself, emerald has meant love and rebirth from the pharaohs to the present, and some of the most storied engagement rings in history carry one. It is also the one great gem whose natural form asks real compromises of a daily ring, which is why this guide is honest about the jardin, the fillers, and the reason we offer laboratory grown emeralds as the better choice for the hand she never stops using.

The Stone

Five Thousand Years of Green

Emerald takes its name from the Greek smaragdos, green stone. It is the green of the mineral beryl, colored by traces of chromium or vanadium, and the grandest member of a family that also gives us pastel blue aquamarine and pastel pink morganite. The first known emerald workings were Egyptian; the ruins in Wadi El Gamal, remembered as Cleopatra’s mines, date to at least 300 BC and likely a thousand years earlier, and the Romans called the region the Emerald Mountains. The Egyptian Book of the Dead names emerald a gift of Thoth, god of wisdom, and mummies were buried with an emerald at the throat for rebirth in the world to come. Cleopatra herself, the stone’s most famous devotee, presented ambassadors with her portrait carved in emerald.

The Americas wrote the next chapter. The Inca worked Colombian emerald from at least the year 1000, and when the Spanish reached South America their galleons carried home greens finer than Europe had ever seen. The 46 carat emerald crowning the Crown of the Andes, one of 447 emeralds set in a hundred pounds of gold and tied by legend to the ransom of the emperor Atahualpa, now rests in the Metropolitan Museum of Art. The Mughal rulers of India prized emerald as the gem of paradise, carving prayers and their own names into Colombian stones, and the 75.47 carat Hooker Emerald at the Smithsonian once fastened the belt of the last Ottoman sultan. Emerald is the May birthstone and the gem of the twentieth anniversary.

The One Decision

The Green of Grass After Rain

Color is nearly the whole value in emerald. The target is a fresh, vivid green, bluish green to pure green, with strong saturation and a tone that stops short of dark: the green of grass after a spring rain, the kind that glows when sunlight finds it. A stone with that glow outranks a bigger, darker, or cleaner stone without it, every time.

Clarity plays by different rules here than anywhere else in the gem world. Natural emerald almost always carries eye visible inclusions, the jardin, French for garden, that grew along with the crystal, and truly clean natural stones are essentially collector goods. Judge the cut on life: even brilliance across the whole face, no dull or washed out zones. The octagonal step cut that bears the stone’s own name, the only cut named for a gem, was born here, designed to honor the shape of emerald rough and carry no fragile corners. And emerald holds one quiet advantage: its density is relatively low, so a one carat emerald faces up noticeably larger than a one carat diamond. Carat for carat, emerald delivers more look.

The Names That Carry Weight

Origin, From Muzo to Zambia

Colombia remains the most important origin for high quality emerald, and Muzo has been its greatest name for centuries; Colombian stones carry the rich green that glows in sunlight. Brazil produces high quality emerald that often runs lighter, and Afghanistan yields stones close to Colombian color, though scarcer in the market. Zambia is the great modern counterweight: its emeralds, colored by vanadium rather than Colombia’s chromium, run a rich, slightly bluish green with clarity that is exceptional for emerald. Zimbabwe’s Sandawana stones are famous for top color in small sizes, and a recent Ethiopian find is producing fine material as well.

Here is the honest read on the names: origin is not a major value factor in emerald. Colombian stones generally bring more, but the premium follows the quality of the color, not the passport, and GIA and other laboratories issue origin reports when an important stone justifies one. The discipline from our gemstone education library holds: the name matters only when the color earns it.

The Checklist

The Emerald Quality Checklist

What our gemologists require before an emerald is set in a RockHer ring.

Factor The Standard
Color Vivid bluish green to pure green, saturated, not too dark. The color must glow.
Clarity The jardin is expected in natural stones. Laboratory grown emerald reaches near eye clean.
Cut Even brilliance across the stone; the emerald cut protects the corners it was designed for.
Shape Emerald cuts lead; cabochons honor the ancient look; rounds and ovals serve smaller sizes.
Polish Very Good or Excellent.
Treatment Fracture filling is standard in natural emerald and disclosed. Laboratory grown needs none.
The Honest Mechanics

The Jardin, the Filler, and the Better Answer

Emerald asks a question no other great gem asks of a daily ring. Here is the whole of it in three cards.

The Reality

The Jardin

Natural emerald is almost never clean; the garden of inclusions grows with the crystal. The stone itself is hard at 7.5 to 8, but the fissures of that internal landscape can weaken the crystal against knocks, which is why many jewelers hesitate to put natural emerald on a hand that works.

The Standard Treatment

Fracture Filling

Most natural emeralds have surface reaching fissures filled with oil, resin, or polymer to lift transparency and quiet the jardin. Accepted with disclosure, but it is maintenance: fillers can degrade with heat, pressure, and solvents, may camouflage vulnerabilities, and may need replacing over the years.

The RockHer Position

Laboratory Grown

First grown in a San Francisco laboratory in 1938, laboratory grown emerald is the identical mineral, with clarity all but the rarest natural stones never reach, no fillers, and nothing to maintain. Only a laboratory report can tell the two apart. For a ring worn every day, we believe it is simply the better emerald, and it is the emerald we offer.

The Green Field

Look Alikes and a Different Kind of Care

Tsavorite, the green garnet of Tanzania and Kenya, comes closest to emerald’s color, usually a touch more yellow green; it is rare in large sizes but brilliant in small ones, which makes it a beautiful emerald alternative in pavé and eternity bands. Green tourmaline arrives generously in large sizes but usually in forest green or dark teal with dark reflections, well below emerald’s glow, though the rare chrome tourmalines come near it; for anyone who loves the deep greens, tourmaline is a gentler priced road.

Care is where emerald differs from every gem on this site, and the rules deserve their own paragraph: warm sudsy water and a tightly woven microfiber cloth, nothing else. Never an ultrasonic machine, never steam, and never a jeweler’s cleaning machine. Store it padded, keep it away from high heat and pressure that can affect fillings, and have the stone removed from its setting before any resizing or repair. A laboratory grown emerald, carrying no fillers, forgives far more, but the gentle habits still serve it.

The Setting

How Our Clients Set Emerald

The diamond halo leads here as it does across the colored stones: a circle of brilliance that lights the green center and shields its edges in the bargain. The emerald solitaire on a delicate pavé band follows, generally with a center of one to two carats, and the three stone design suits emerald in either role, holding the center or bringing color to a diamond’s flanks. Emerald studs, eternity bands, and wedding rings carry the fresh green of spring beyond the engagement ring. Every setting is made to order in Los Angeles.

The diamonds around an emerald are held to our diamond standard: every accent stone we recommend is evaluated by ROSI™, our gemological intelligence, built by our gemologists.

An Honest Word
We will not sell you a fragile stone and call it a heritage. The emerald we set is the one built to be worn.

Natural emerald is one of the glories of the earth, and for a collector, a pendant, or an occasion piece it has no rival. For an engagement ring that lives on a working hand for fifty years, the jardin and its fillers are a real cost that most sellers leave out of the romance. Our answer is the laboratory grown emerald: the same mineral, the glowing green chosen by eye, none of the maintenance. If you want the natural stone anyway, with its history in your hand, we will tell you exactly what you are taking on, in writing, before you take it on.

Questions

Emerald Questions, Answered

What is the most valuable emerald color?
A fresh, vivid green, like grass after a spring rain: bluish green to pure green, with strong saturation and a tone that stops short of dark. Color is nearly the whole value in emerald. A stone that glows green in sunlight outranks a bigger, darker, or cleaner stone that does not.
Why do emeralds have so many inclusions?
Because the garden grows with the crystal. Natural emerald almost always carries eye visible inclusions the trade calls the jardin, French for garden, and truly clean natural stones are so rare they are essentially collector goods. The emerald itself is reasonably hard at 7.5 to 8 on the Mohs scale, but the fissures of that internal landscape can introduce weakness into the crystal, which is why many jewelers hesitate to recommend natural emerald for a ring worn every day.
What is emerald fracture filling?
The standard treatment for natural emerald. Surface reaching fissures are filled with an oil, resin, or polymer that raises apparent transparency and softens the look of the jardin. It is accepted with disclosure, but it is maintenance: fillers can degrade with heat, pressure, and solvents and may need replacement over time, which is also why ultrasonic and steam cleaning are off limits for natural emerald.
Are laboratory grown emeralds real emeralds?
Yes. A laboratory grown emerald is the same mineral with identical chemical, physical, and optical properties; the process was first perfected in a San Francisco laboratory in 1938. The difference is condition: laboratory grown emeralds reach clarity that all but the rarest natural stones never approach, with no fillers and nothing to maintain, and only a laboratory identification report can separate the two. That is why RockHer offers laboratory grown emeralds as the better choice for an engagement ring worn daily.
Do emeralds look bigger than diamonds of the same carat weight?
Yes. Emerald has a relatively low specific gravity, so a one carat emerald is noticeably larger face up than a one carat diamond, and its saturated color makes the presence even stronger. Carat for carat, emerald delivers more look.
How do I care for an emerald?
Gently. Clean with warm sudsy water and a tightly woven microfiber cloth, never an ultrasonic machine or steam, and do not let a jeweler machine clean it either. Store it padded, keep it from high heat and pressure that can affect fillings, and have the stone removed from its setting before any resizing or repair. Laboratory grown emeralds, with no fillers, are far less demanding, though the same gentle habits serve them well.
Talk to a Jeweler

Considering an emerald? See the green with a gemologist.

John Anderson, our Lead Gemologist, puts emeralds on video with you in daylight, laboratory grown against natural, so the glow and the jardin stop being abstractions. Every stone comes with its identification and disclosure in writing. The consultation is complimentary and there is no obligation.

1-800-779-1726
40 Day Returns60 Day Complimentary ResizingLifetime WarrantyGIA & IGI Certified