Buyer’s Guide to Emerald Cut Diamonds

Beyonce. Jennifer Lopez. Jennifer Lawrence. Amal Clooney. Angelina Jolie. So many of the world’s most powerful and accomplished women have another thing in common: they all wear elegant emerald cut engagement rings. This sophisticated diamond cut stands out from the crowd with its icy perfection and dramatic geometry. An emerald cut engagement ring is the perfect choice for a confident, strong woman who loves streamlined modern design.

Shop Emerald Diamonds

The History of Emerald Cut Diamonds

The emerald cut has a long and distinguished history: it’s based on the earliest faceted diamond shape called the table cut. In the 14th century, cutters discovered that they could use diamond dust to grind away the top point of a diamond crystal creating a flat table facet that allows you to see into the stone. Later they added a faceted culet on the bottom.

emerald diamond
The trick that finally unleashed the brilliance and dispersion of diamond were stepped facets around the stone that reflected light back as brilliance.

These early step cuts were refined over the centuries, becoming popular in Art Deco jewelry designs in the 1920s. Step cuts were particularly popular for emeralds because the beveled corners of the shape protect the corners against chipping while still providing bright flashes of color. The rectangular step cut, which suits the natural elongated shape of emerald crystals, became so closely associated with these green gems that it was named after them. The modern diamond emerald cut with 58 facets was created in the 1940s.

Why We Love Emerald Cut Diamonds

The distinctive long and large facets of the emerald cut diamond make it easy to love. You’ll often read that an emerald cut has “less brilliance” but this isn't really accurate. The larger facets of an emerald cut return brighter and larger reflections of light back to your eyes: it’s a different optical effect than the smaller but more numerous reflections in a brilliant cut.

The optical effect in an emerald cut is called the “hall of mirrors” effect: the facets reflect each other across the pavilion of the stone.

emerald cut diamond

When you turn the diamond, you’ll see the entire gem flash with light. A well-proportioned emerald cut diamond is undeniably stunning.

An emerald cut diamond also appears about 5% larger than a round brilliant diamond of the same carat weight because it is shallower in depth. In addition, the elongated proportions of the emerald cut also fool the eye into thinking the taller shape is larger than a round. That is also why large emerald cut diamond engagement rings like the 18-carat gem Beyonce received from Jay Z or the 16-carat emerald cut diamond Jennifer Lopez received from A-Rod look so large.

The other reason we love emerald cut diamonds? They can cost as much as 25% less than round brilliants of the same quality.

How to Buy Emerald Cut Diamonds

Although the quality factors used to evaluate emerald cut diamonds are the same as the 4Cs of round brilliant diamonds, you will probably want to make different choices when you are shopping for emerald cuts.

The factor that you’ll immediately notice first is the length to width ratio: a comparison of how square or long the rectangle of the shape is. A ratio of 1 would be square and a ratio of 1.7 would be long and skinny. Which you like best is a matter of personal taste but most people prefer something in the middle.

emerald cut diamond length to width ratio diagram

Clarity has a much bigger impact on the beauty of an emerald cut diamond than on brilliant shapes.

The large flashing facets that make emerald cut diamonds so appealing also highlight any inclusions inside the stone, lighting them up like they are under a spotlight. For this reason, you will want to make sure you choose an emerald cut diamond without a large inclusion in the center that will be reflected around the stone.

emerald cut diamond video
But since emerald cut diamonds are less expensive per carat than round brilliants, you can afford to upgrade your quality.

Unlike round brilliants, GIA does not offer cut grades for emerald cuts. The grades you see on the report are for polish and symmetry, not for proportions. Still the grades for polish and symmetry can give you an indication of the quality of the cutting.

What ROSI Recommends

We programmed ROSI, an artificial intelligence powered by IBM’s Watson, to comb through all the emerald cuts available on the market to find the best balance of quality and value for your budget. See the best emerald cut diamond for your budget.

ROSI generally recommends a color of H for an emerald cut diamond: the flashing facets will still look almost colorless. Clarity should be at least SI1 (or better whenever possible.) The most visible factor in the appearance of your emerald cut is the length to width ratio. ROSI recommends a ratio of 1.3 to 1.5, which gives you a pleasing rectangular shape.

Depth % for Emerald Diamonds
Table % of Emerald Diamonds

Emerald Cut Quality Checklist

  • Color: H
  • Clarity: SI1 or better
  • Ratio: 1.3 to 1.5
  • Depth: 61%-68%
  • Table: 60%-69%
  • Polish: Very Good-Excellent
  • Symmetry: Very Good-Excellent

Like a round brilliant, cut quality of the emerald cut depends on its angles and proportions. Large depth and table percentage ranges will include combinations that work well together and combinations that don’t. ROSI eliminates all diamonds that are outside of 58-75 depth percentage and 56-75 table percentage and then chooses combinations of proportions that provide the brightest possible gem.

ROSI generally recommends a depth percentage between 61 to 68, which is the best balance between brilliance and size (the less depth, the larger your emerald cut diamond will appear.) ROSI usually recommends a table percentage of 60-69. ROSI always recommends very good to excellent polish and a very good to excellent symmetry, which together indicate a well-crafted diamond.

Emerald Cut vs Radiant Cut vs Asscher

The two diamond cuts that are the most similar to the emerald cut are the radiant cut diamond and the Asscher cut diamond. The Radiant cut has a similar shape to the emerald: rectangular with cut corners that make it an octagon. But unlike the emerald cut’s step facets, the Radiant has triangular brilliant cut facets giving it a “crushed ice” look. The Asscher cut, which was invented in 1902, is basically a square emerald cut. It generally has a much smaller table than a traditional square emerald cut and a distinctive X pattern in its facets because its corners are proportionally larger. With its smaller table, an Asscher is a bit deeper than an emerald cut and looks a bit smaller for its carat weight, similar to a round brilliant.

compare emerald cut diamond

Best Settings for Emerald Cut Engagement Rings

Our customer’s favorite setting for an emerald cut engagement ring is a refined emerald cut solitaire with a pave band. For something a bit more intricate, an emerald cut halo engagement ring has extra detail (and extra diamonds.). Because this cut is sleek and minimal, many brides also choose a simple solitaire: a bezel set emerald cut engagement ring is particularly sleek. Three stone styles are also popular, especially an emerald cut engagement ring with tapered baguettes on each side, which is the style of the famous Jennifer Lopez emerald cut ring.

emerald cut diamond engagement ring

You’d be surprised how far your money can go shopping for an emerald cut engagement ring.

emerald cut diamond engagement ring with pave diamond band

Pave Band

Kelly
emerald cut diamond halo engagement ring

Halo

Dylan
bezel set emerald diamond engagement ring

Plain Bezel

Hayley
three stone emerald diamond engagement ring

Tapered Baguette

June
Please upgrade your browser to access RockHer.com
We built RockHer on the latest technologies. That means RockHer.com works best with the following browsers. Please upgrade to one of these browsers for the best experience.